I only use liquid eyeliner and I have tried so many. If they stay, then they smudge. If they don't smudge, then they chip away. This does neither! I've passed out with it on and woke up next day and it didnt even budge.

I bought an eyeliner from different companies and always says it is a non smearing and lasting but non of them is true until I tried this eyeliner , it is cheap but the best I got, it really stays and doesn't smear.

it does the job of staying on for long periods of time, but the viscosity of the liquid was so thick that I could not even get a winged eyeliner right.

I'm not good with these dip liners, usually marker pen types but I like this one because it has last me over a year I guess because I use it less but it's very dark, bold, and can last through 8 hours at most for me!

Please don't buy this. It looks bad. And it does not remove easy. Worst makeup product I ever bought. Wish I could get my money back. I may find the address of the company and ship it back to let them know how bad it is.

This product should have zero stars. I used it once and it does not come off with warm water, soap, or makeup remover. My eyes hurt so bad from trying to remove this. It applies horribly as well. Worst product ever.

i love it really stays on and easy to work with the only thing is you need a good make up remover to get it off i use coco butter and thats all i need but its true to it being waterproof.

its waterproof it doesn't go away Even if I go into the pool or if I cry or if I wake up the next day with it which I don't recommend but it doesn't look bad.

first liquid eyeliner i've found that is actually waterproof! could stay on for 24hr w minor touch ups. a good oil based cleanser would be good to take it off.

When I open it was totally empty