[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I tried this liner in the shade Bronzage. Overall- I was very disappointed in this product:( The formula was very dry - almost as if my product was dried out inside the container. The color was not bright and did not stand out the way that I had hoped it would. I applied my regular black liner and then used this liner above that. I didnt feel as though the addition of this product did anything for my makeup look. I wanted to like it but sadly, it is a no for me!:(

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was super excited to try this eyeliner. Gun metal is basically just black. The applicator is hard to handle and is extra thick so unless you like thick eyeliner you are going to want to avoid this one. The formula seems to be the kind that needs multiple layers because it doesn't come out evenly colored.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] So I was super excited about this one bc I do use a lot of bronze tones when doing eyeshadow and thought this would give me a perfect subtle wing to help elongate my eyes. I was kinda disappointed at the pigment, maybe its the chromatic tone that dulled it down but it honestly doesnt look like I have anything on, or like if I didnt wash my eye makeup off properly. One way I would wear it is to put like a bronze shadow over it considering its liquid it will help keep glitter/shimmer on the lash line. Thats the only use I found for it so far

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really wanted to love this liquid eyeliner but unfortunately it left something to be desired. It is a rather light color so doesn't show up well unless there is a thick line of it. However it does go on quite smoothly, but I probably won't purchase in the future.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Received in a voxbox. I don't really use eyeliners that aren't black, but I liked the formula of this product. I probably won't use it a ton but it's not bad for someone who use more color. The bronzey gold shimmer was nice !

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Hi everyone I just wanted to say I absolutely love this eyeliner its affordable and so easy to apply and the packaging is beautiful and it lasts all Day I have nothing bad to say I would definitely recommend to everyone who loves eyeliner

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the packaging of this product, what I don't like is the tip. I like to do a thin liner and it's just not possible with this tip. It's a short fat round applicator with the Tiniest pointed tip at the end. So the only line you can achieve is a thick one which is not for me because I have same almond eyes. The color also doesn't give off to much of a metallic gray color. It also take a while to dry. So it's not something I would go out and purchase on my own. It does stay on the eyes well. So smudging so far.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] So easy to apply; the color is pigmented, and stays on for hours! When I opened the product at first, I was a bit confused because I couldn't see a lot of it.. but man does it deliver! It made me step out of my comfort zone of always using black for eyeliner, and even more for always sticking to a winged-eye look. I love love love it!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I am very pale and the eyeliner doesn't show very well on my skin tone. it is beautiful though and perfect for the holidays! It is festive and cute. I would recommend it, just need to have a darker eyeshadow base.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This eyeliner is advertised as a metallic liner but it doesnt really come off that way. However, I like the applicator and still like the look of the liner even if it doesnt completely match the description. The eyeliner works great for the fox eye look and has definitely made its way into my makeup routine.