I have nothing really to say about the eye liner. The product was exactly like I expected and wanted. I've use this brand many times and I really like the fact that you don't have to sharpen the pencil, you simply just roll it up a tiny bit as you use it. The ones you must sharpen are horrible.

This eyeliner is a nice warm brown. The ad gave me the impression that it might be a little too red, but the reviews convinced me to take a chance. They were all correct. This is a really lovely color,kind of like milk chocolate. Walmart is offering a cash rebate for a couple dollars, so it's a great deal.

THEE best eyeliner I've come across in ages. I've been using L'oreal(sic), Amay and Neutrogena eyeliners because I couldn't settle on one I really like. Either they've too hard to remove, run or wear off easy, but this one is a keeper. Love the easy application, but stays put. Easy to remove. The richness of the colors really stands out. I love how it makes my small eyes stand out!

I'm in my early 40s and have literally been using this liner since I was in my early teens. Applies smooth and stays on all day. Only complaint is sometimes the covers for both ends breaks, but that's probably due to being put in and out of a makeup bag. Will always stick with this classic!

Covergirl Perfect point plus is another of my go to items. I use it to eyeline my lower eye as I hate pencils that are rough on your delicate under eye skin. Also no need to sharpen it as it comes out from the bottom easily.

I was able to get the eye liner that I use and desire easily and successfully. The product is great and Walmart made the whole process terrific!

I've been using this product for years. I especially love the expresso shade. Very easy to apply as it glides on smoothly. The only thing about this eye liner is it tends to always smudge underneath my eyes, even though I only apply on the top eyelid.

I've tried nearly every brand of eyeliner Walmart carries and several from brands online and still haven't found that one go-to dark brown eyeliner. With this one, the color was right, and i liked the smoothness.It glided without any color skipping, but I need all day color and this one had no staying power. Within a hr, it was gone but I gave it to my friend. she wanted its because its creates the same size precision line she uses on her eyebrows.

I got this. Eyeliner for. My waterline. It doesn't show up at. All. It's like hard waxy, and just does absolutely nothing z even. When I tried to put it on my wrist and draw a line. It just doesn't show up. Waste of money.

Would love to give a better review however, when I tried to remove the packaging it had been glued directly to the pencil and no matter what I did I could not remove the glue to even remove the caps. Ended up tossing it into the trash.